Lease vs Buy Car Comparison

Compare 36-mo lease total cost vs. 5-yr purchase + resale. Same out-of-pocket cash basis.

Inputs

Result

Cheaper option
Lease
Lease saves $9,880 over the comparison period.
  • Vehicle price$40,000
  • Lease total cost$19,200
  • Lease down$3,000
  • Lease payments$16,200 (36 × $450)
  • Buy total out-of-pocket$29,080
  • Buy down$5,000
  • Buy total payments$42,080 (60 × $701)
  • Resale recovered−$18,000
  • Difference$9,880
  • CheaperLease

Step-by-step

  1. Lease total = down + monthly × months = $3,000 + 36 × $450 = $19,200.
  2. Buy out-of-pocket = down + total payments − resale = $5,000 + $42,080 − $18,000 = $29,080.
  3. Lease is cheaper by $9,880.

How to use this calculator

  • Enter lease + buy terms.
  • Estimate resale at end of buy term (KBB/Edmunds).
  • Compare totals.

About this calculator

Lease vs. buy is mostly an asset-ownership question. Lease: lower monthly + always-new car + no resale hassle, but you own nothing at the end. Buy: higher monthly but you own the car and recover residual value at sale. Over 6+ years buying typically wins financially. Over 3 years lease is often cheaper. Lease usage limits (10-15k miles/yr) matter — over-mileage charges can be $0.20-0.30/mi.

Frequently asked

Short ownership horizons (3 years), high-mileage business use isn't needed, or you want to always drive new. Lower out-of-pocket monthly = better cash flow.

Related calculators