Health Plan: Deductible vs Premium

Total annual cost = premiums × 12 + expected medical × cost-share until OOPM.

Inputs

Result

Loading calculator…
—

How to use this calculator

  • Enter premium + plan limits + expected medical use.
  • Compare totals across plan options.

About this calculator

Health plans trade off premium vs. cost-share. Low-deductible plans charge higher premiums but lower per-visit. High-deductible (HDHP) charges low premium, you cover first $3,000+ of care, but caps your worst-case at OOP max. The break-even depends on actual usage — light users prefer HDHP; heavy users (chronic conditions, planned surgery) prefer low-deductible.

Frequently asked

OOP max includes premiums?+
No — OOP max is your medical cost cap. Premiums are separate. Total annual cost = premium + OOP medical (capped at OOP max).
HDHP advantage?+
Lower premiums + HSA eligibility (triple tax advantage). For healthy people: huge savings.
What's coinsurance?+
% you pay after deductible until OOP max. 20% means insurer pays 80%, you pay 20%.
In-network vs. OON?+
OON usually doesn't count toward deductible/OOP max, or counts at lower rate. Stay in-network when possible.
Pre-deductible coverage?+
Many plans cover preventive care (annual physical, screenings) at 100% before deductible. Check plan SBC.

Related calculators

HSA Tax Savings Calculator
Tax saved = contribution × marginal tax bracket. Triple tax advantage with HDHP.
FSA Tax Savings Calculator
Tax saved = contribution × marginal rate. Use-it-or-lose-it (with $640 max carryover 2025).
COBRA vs ACA Marketplace Cost
COBRA = full premium + 2% admin. Marketplace = unsubsidized premium with possible subsidy.
ACA Subsidy Estimator
Premium tax credit caps benchmark Silver plan at 0-8.5% of income (sliding scale).
Insurance Bundling Savings
Auto + Home from same carrier typically saves 5-25%.
Life Insurance Cash Surrender Value
Cash surrender = cash value − surrender charges. Estimate before cancelling permanent policy.

More tools you might like

Hand-picked tools that pair well with this one — same audience, same intent.

HSA Tax Savings Calculator
Calc

Tax saved = contribution × marginal tax bracket. Triple tax advantage with HDHP.

FSA Tax Savings Calculator
Calc

Tax saved = contribution × marginal rate. Use-it-or-lose-it (with $640 max carryover 2025).

Life Insurance Cash Surrender Value
Calc

Cash surrender = cash value − surrender charges. Estimate before cancelling permanent policy.

Insurance Bundling Savings
Calc

Auto + Home from same carrier typically saves 5-25%.

COBRA vs ACA Marketplace Cost
Calc

COBRA = full premium + 2% admin. Marketplace = unsubsidized premium with possible subsidy.

Health Insurance Prior Authorization Appeal
Docs

Appeal of a prior-authorization denial for a specific medical service - drug, procedure, or DME.